The U.S. Department of Education announced an investigation today (Oct. 26) into the Palo Alto Unified School District over a questionnaire that allegedly asked students about their sexual orientations, gender identities, mental and physical health conditions and family economic status.
Students were required to complete the questionnaire as part of the district’s newly mandated Ethnic Studies course, the Department of Education said.
The Department of Education said the district needs to get parental consent before asking students “invasive” questions.
“Schools in California seem to be collecting a myriad of protected and private information on students without involving parents, raising serious concerns that they deliberately keep parents in the dark about the most sensitive information pertaining to their children,” Director of the Student Privacy Policy Office Frank Miller said in a statement.
Superintendent Jason Glass said the district will cooperate with the Department of Education. He said parents can ask to review class materials by contacting their child’s teacher or principal, and the Ethnic Studies curriculum is available online.
“Parents have a right to know what their children are learning and to make decisions about sensitive personal matters. We take that seriously, along with our responsibility to teach Ethnic Studies well. Those commitments are not in conflict,” Glass said. “If we find something that should be done differently, we will fix it.”
The Department of Education is also investigating districts in San Francisco and Monterey.
The Department of Education alleged that parents weren’t allowed to review Ethnic Studies curriculum, in violation of the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment passed in 1978.
“Education leaders in California must stop undermining parental rights and we will work with these districts to bring them into full compliance with federal laws,” Miller said.
The Palo Alto school board voted 3-2 to make Ethnic Studies a graduation requirement at a long and tense meeting on Jan. 23, 2025.
Board members received 3,700 emails related to Ethnic Studies in two days leading up to the meeting, and the crowd overflowed outside of the meeting room.
Students and teachers were mostly in favor of mandating the course, but a group of parents said they didn’t trust the content.
“I think that the fear is based on an ideological framework around oppressor-oppressed that will make some students in this school district feel unsafe,” board member Rowena Chiu said at the meeting.
Chiu and board member Alison Kamhi voted against the mandate. Shounak Dharap and Shana Segal were in favor of the mandate, and Josh Salcman was the swing vote.

The survey was invasive but the more sinister part is it’s designed to lead to indoctrination. This is Newsom’s plan.
Governor Newsom actually vetoed an ethnic studies (blame whitey) bill as a requirement for high school graduation during the height of the George Floyd revolution in 2020, but later got the memo in 2021 and has been a shill on advocating against “white privilege” ever since.
If you think this all started with Newsom or is “leading” to indoctrination, then we’re living in two different realities. Top down mass indoctrination from kindergarten to graduate school (and lately in the corporate world) emphasizing obedience, collectivism, ideological conformity and, more specifically, identity politics, critical race theory, and radical gender ideologies…has been going on now for several generations in all 50 states and the entire western world.
[Part removed — Terms of Use violation. Please don’t cite unverified information as fact.]
Well, Newsom is for it right now and he’s also promoting study groups about reparations even though it’s not clear if he’s backing reparations or not.
How secure is the information collected? Some of it, like sexual orientation and gender identity, could be used against the kids in the future in their adult lives. Kids go through all sorts of phases and may adopt identities which are either transitory or which they will prefer to keep private. Is a 45 year old CEO going to want to read about his adolescent identity as one of the 37 newly discovered genders in some future media piece?
[Comment removed — Terms of Use violation, No. 5]
I know PAUSD is a basic aid district and only gets $4 million from federal, but you’re already looking at -$33 million to cut by end of the fiscal year and can’t afford to lose anymore funding. Stop shooting yourself in the foot at the taxpayers expense with this nonsense and get back to the basics of educating our children! PAUSD had over $100 million in reserves a fiscal year ago and now they have to cut -$33 million by July 1, 2027. Any PAUSD employee that was a part of that kind of financial meltdown needs to fired for cause, full stop. Did I miss a stock market collapse? Did the property values and property taxes collapse? NO, they actually were higher than PAUSD anticipated. So where did all that money go in a very short period of time? Is it in the realm of possibility that the PAUSD audit could potentially reveal negligence beyond just bad accounting? Does PAUSD have all the receipts to justify that kind of financial swing? Maybe real journalists and concerned tax payers should go through the PAUSD budget and start asking questions about certain line items. Probably better to do that now before employees targeted for layoffs start naming examples of unscrupulous waste at board meetings for all to hear. PAUSD is just a microcosm of bad money management, this is clearly a systematic problem. How many of you remember our great state of California had a $97 BILLION covid surplus that expeditiously turned into a -$32 BILLION deficit. Maybe we should just audit the entire state too before there are any more tax increases, especially to cover basic resident services like schools and transportation.
Toss the Federal Government into your audit demand while you are at it.
So we’re going to excuse PAUSD because, you know, the federal government?
I didn’t say excuse PAUSD. Bob brought up deficits and implied financial impropriety at the PAUSD and state level. Since the Federal Government is running a record deficit, all I said was that bears auditing attention too.
Simple as that my friend.
Thanks for the clarification. But the ethnic studies audit is of a different sort, asking for information that could be used in a run-up to an ethnic studies requirement. A lot of people don’t want required ethnic studies and think it should be an elective. The district could easily accommodate this through computerized scheduling. You used to have a choice between a semester of economics or sex, relationship and family issues, or some such, in your senior year. This could be the same for ninth grade.
The Dept. of Education wants to know why Palo Alto school teachers would be asking kids about their sexual preferences. Seems perverted to me. I can see why they’re investigating this. Are they going to teach different stuff to a boy who wants to be a girl than they would teach to a boy who likes girls? If the answer is “no,” then why ask? Just teach them all the same thing. I’m sure some instructors will see the survey results and use it to decide which kids they want to “date,” like [Portion removed — Terms of Use violation.]
This is amusing if a bit far-fetched.
Nearly everything the Trump Administration does nowadays is for dubious motives, and this sortie is no different.
That said, at least some of this “ethnic studies” content is outright quackery with no place in a public education system. Shame on us that we can’t deal with this stuff ourselves, without the Feds getting involved.
“Palo Alto Unified School District (PAUSD) Superintendent Jason Glass stated that schools do not ask students to complete the specific exercises being investigated by the federal government, clarifying that they are only included in the syllabus as a reference or teacher example”.
Should not take the FEDS long to get to the truth here.
You left out the best part. The Ethnic Studies class included a game of “Wheel of Privilege.” Danae Reynolds would spin the wheel and the kids would have to guess the word or phrase.