Opinion: Kou’s views on the Cubberley deal changed when council put a sales tax on the ballot

BY DAVE PRICE
Daily Post Editor

Nobody expects political advertising to be honest, but given all of the respected community leaders who are on the Yes-on-J bandwagon, you’d expect more from that campaign.

Measure J would permanently raise the sales tax by a half cent so the city could pay the school district $65.5 million for a piece of the Cubberley Community Center. 

Last week, the Yes-on-J side released an ad that made it sound as if former Palo Alto Mayor Lydia Kou favored Measure J. She favored the acquisition in 2024 but she doesn’t like the sales tax hike that was proposed this year, long after she was off council. The ad didn’t say that. 

Among her objections:

Measure J has no expiration. It’s a regressive tax that hits the low- and middle-income people the hardest. And while it’s said to be a tax for Cubberley, there’s nothing stopping the city from using the money for other government activities.

And she points out that the ballot language says the tax will be in effect “…until ended by voters.” But Kou said she questions how many voters understand how much money and effort it would take to repeal a tax. 

Some of the Yes-on-J people wish Kou had raised her objections in 2024 when she was part of the committee negotiating the Cubberley deal. But how could she? The tax hadn’t been decided back then. At that time, they were talking about a bond measure.

20 Comments

  1. The issue isn’t whether you’re for or against renovating Cubberley, though some of the “Yes on J” proponents try to position it that way.

    The issue is, “at any price?” That’s a reasonable, even critical question.

  2. Yes, one of the biggest reasons to vote no on Measure J is how dishonest the proponents have been about it. We’ve voted to fund things that required 2/3 majority, and the good thing about it is the clear mandate. Measure J smacks of a certain person leaving council soon (JLH) wanting to do the most expedient thing to get a star on her resume for future political aspirations, rather than doing the work of bringing the public together to make a bond vote happen.

    The other reasons to vote NO on Measure J are legion, but one in particular that doesn’t get talked about enough is that in order to even bring another general tax to voters, Palo Alto had to ask the state legislature for a special law, and the only way that law will survive a legal challenge is urgent fiscal circumstances which just don’t hold up to scrutiny. The City of Campbell had far more defensible reasons but was still sued over their doing the same thing, so the money is being collected from residents and isn’t even available to the city pending resolution of appeals, which could take years. Given the far more tenuous justification Palo Alto had to get this exception, it’s very likely if Measure J passes, we’ll have the same suit on our hands, which will cost money, take the funds out of reach anyway, and make moving forward at Cubberley much harder.

    Just vote NO on Measure J and ask the Council to do better.

  3. You should be against Measure J if any of the money raised in the sales tax goes to PAUSD resulting in an unearned windfall.

  4. Thank you to Price and the Daily for stating the obvious, the deal changed after Kou was off council.
    The way in which some of her former colleagues have spoken about her is disrespectful and says more about their poor morals and honesty than it does about Kou.

  5. No on J is the responsible choice given the city and PAUSD’s record of squandering taxpayer dollars, making Lydia Kou’s inability to articulate that case all the more disappointing for a former mayor.

  6. Tax measures always have red herrings, and they are almost always the same. No matter what proponents say the tax is for, there’s almost always language that allows the use of funds for anything. Going into the general fund. The other is that the taxes never sunset. If people want true accountability, they’d demand both of these in all proposed tax revenue increasing measures. We all get that being honest wouldn’t produce a desired result of raising revenues, but this is the inherent dishonesty.

  7. Wait a minute. Kou is entitled to change her mind, but that doesn’t explain why the ballot arguments signed by Kou say “We don’t even know how the $65.5 million price for the property was determined”(Uh, she was on the committee that negotiated that price, obviously she did know) and “Why should taxpayers pay to transfer land we already own?” (Again, KOU NEGOTIATED THE PRICE with the PAUSD, told the public it was a good deal, and as a former councilmember knows very well that the City of Palo Alto doesn’t cover the same constituents as the PAUSD, which includes Stanford and part of Los Altos). Seriously question her motives in making those statements on the ballot and can’t understand why she is trying to sink a project she once vocally supported. The loser here will be our community, when the PAUSD sells the land to someone else and there goes our chance at a beautiful community center that all could use.

  8. The ad in today’s paper is more of the same. To advertise “100% Dedicated to Cubberley” continues the deceptive practices of this campaign. Who is advising them to proceed this way? The current City Council passed a resolution committing that they would spend the revenue on Cubberley. That council will not exist after this election. Even if it did, resolutions are not binding. This means that Cubberley can be bumped from the budget, which is determined annually, and the money can be spent on myriad government services instead. Had the Yes on J Team chosen to add a sunset clause to this tax increase, I think there would be less resistance to it. But, they opted for a forever tax. They also opted to use deceptive ballot language to woo voters into thinking the revenue is for Cubberley only.

    Palo Alto Community Center (“PACC”) and Palo Alto City Council (also “PACC”) need to do better when asking voters to turn on the tax tap forever.

  9. Yes, thank you for defending Lydia Kou u against the transparent incessant and illogical attacks that insult our intelligence.

    Yes, it’s a regressive tax that hits low-and middle-income people, including seniors on fixed income the hardest. But that’s unfortunately consistent with “our leaders'” usual indifference to how their free-spending ways hit their constituents in the form of constant utility rate hikes that drastically outpace inflation.

    What about the struggling retailers and restaurants whose businesses are AGAIN being disrupted by ANOTHER revision to the parklet rules which forces restaurants to pay to redesign their parklets to conform to the new even absurd design rules that leave customers exposed to rain during El Nino.

    News flash Retail Committee: If people can’t dine comfortably in the rain and cold, this won’t help the other stores on the street!

    Guess it’s time for the highly paid retail consultants to redo their Streetscape plan!

    Seriously, why give the city a another blank check without a sunset clause like the utilities transfer tax where there’s no accountability for how they spend the $25,000,000+ they collect from us each year in utility OVERCHARGES in perpetuity.

    Shame on the Yes on J folks for attacking Kou instead of addressing real concerns!

  10. Measure J increases sales tax by 0.5%, no sunset clause, estimated to generate $15 million per year.
    Proponents of Measure J want to spend $65 million to purchase 7 acres of the Cubberley site from the School District. They also want to redevelop the site costing somewhere between $300 million to $500 million (Cubberly master plan).
    Proponents haven’t presented a plan on (1) how to fund the redevelopment, (2) what are the stages/phases of redevelopment, (3) how much time it would take to reach stages of redevelopment.
    The plan is important, because the Measure J does not bind the funds to Cubberly; the City of Palo Alto has a projected deficit for the coming year of $15 million (see website Paloaltocivic.com, january 20, 2026 meeting report. Would the Measure J tax be used to address the city deficit, and push out the purchase and renovation of Cubberley?
    That’s why Measure J is flawed, and the city council should put a better ballot measure with (1) controls so that the money is only spent on Cubberley, (2) a sunset clause.

  11. Tax Payer, I think Kou’s doing a fine job of articulating why J needs to be defeated and then revised — which is why her opponents are spending so much time and money attacking her instead of addressing the real problems with J.

    Shame on them for insulting our intelligence with their distractions.

  12. It’d be funny if this tax passed and then, due to decisions by council, all of the sales-tax producing businesses close or move out of town. OK, not funny. But given this council, probable.

  13. Remember the “Mean Girls” emails that came out in May? They flippantly blackballed applicants for a city commission if they supported Israel or didn’t believe the PAUSD suicide narrative. The two main “Mean Girls” are now leading Measure J — Julie Lythcott-Haims is chairwoman of the council committee that negotiated this deal and Jennifer DiBrienza is head of the Measure J campaign. If I recall correctly, Lydia gave this nasty group of women their name — the Mean Girls. I’m sure they hated the label. So they’re getting back at Lydia. Funny though, Lydia has a better reputation in Palo Alto than either Julie Lythcott-Haims or Jennifer DiBrienza. And while Joe Simitian has picked a side in this mess, it should be careful because it will sully his reputation too.

  14. I don’t know if Lydia Kou nicknamed that group, but the Yes on J team is certainly taking swipes at her. Why? Because she has the guts to stand up and point out the serious flaws in Measure J? Kou is a true “servant leader”. From organizing Quakeville to filling sandbags and knocking on doors in the flood zone in 2023 to voluntarily doing fire watch at Foothills Park to serving on City Council, she walks the walk.

    Measure J reminds me of the High Speed Rail initiative: great concept, but critical details are missing and we should know those NOW, not after the election. We know only the cost of the land. What are the projected costs for renovation? New buildings? How are those costs to be funded? When will the work begin? If the City will be borrowing money, what’s the cost of that?

    Julie Lythcott-Haims professes to be baffled by Lydia Kou’s position on J. Well, I am baffled by the approach “Palo Alto Community Center” (Lythcott-Haims, DiBrienza, and Burt, best I can tell) are taking on this. The full page ad in today’s paper doubles-down on the deception that has defined this Yes on J campaign from the get-go. Claiming “100% Dedicated to Cubberley” sounds great, but that is campaign talk because Council resolutions are not binding. That might not matter as much as is does if this measure included a sunset clause. But it doesn’t.

  15. Annette, thank you. Your post reminds me of Julie Lythcott-Haims’ reaction to Lydia Kou’s sandbag efforts where Kou single-handedly organized it, directed residents to sandbag sites, warned them to bring their own shovels etc. while the City and staff did nothing.

    How did Lythcott-Haims, a very junior council member, react? Did she offer to help Kou fill sandbags? Did she organize her own neighborhood? Was she inspired to help by the actions of a more senior council member:? Did she call out the city for its inaction in a major emergency or push Staff to support Kou’s efforts?

    Nope. She teamed up with Ed Shikada’s office and his communications manager to explore censoring online communications like Kou’s because they might “confuse” residents most of whom are quite familiar with online communications!

    This type of transparently deceptive spin from one of the “mean girls” who freely censors and demeans others regardless of the facts and/or merit isn’t baffling at all. it’s typical for one who lied about her reasons for leaving Stanford, who lied about the Paly student petition to push her own agenda to prevent any examination of the school’s lax approach to bullying which you’d think from all her virtue-signaling about equity and values would be a top priority, who lies about those disagreeing with her, claiming that they support Jim Crow, that they’re racist, that they’re elitist …

    Nope, Lythcott-Haims’ attacks on Kou aren’t baffling; they’re consistent with her usual “weapons of mass distraction” to avoid real issues like improving Measure J.

    No wonder two newspapers have called Measure J and the well-financed campaign deceptive.

  16. Don’t start me on Ed Shikada. Ed Shikada is a walking monument to bureaucratic dysfunction: a highly compensated empty suit who seems to have mastered the art of drawing a public salary while leaving the public to wonder what exactly they’re paying for. What a disgrace!

    • I would say that California city managers in general are probably the most over-compensated group in the entire world. And they frequently run city finances right into the ground.

  17. Cabal indeed; they somehow manage to land new positions of responsibility no matter their track record. My guess is that the hiring process needs improvement. Being selected after a thorough, complete, and fair search is better for all parties, including the candidate. That did not happen after Benest left and a new CM was needed. Given what we’ve seen, I question if Shikada would even have been a finalist. Why must this city rely on consultants as much as it does when we are paying top dollar to the City Manager? I thought, apparently wrongly, that there was a correlation between compensation and capability. Shikada’s level of disengagement and lack of regard for residents is exceptionally high. Residents should not have to point out an obvious years-long problem, provide data that quantifies the extent of that problem, and suggest solutions to the CM. Retail areas should not be blighted. Filth downtown should not be a problem. Getting through the planning process should not require strategic thinking and extraordinary patience on the applicant’s part. Administrative staffing levels should not be at unnecessarily high levels in a city that does not fully staff or equip its fire department. The shortcomings are serious and, alarmingly, potentially life-threatening if PAFD response time is too long. There’s a lot to be fixed and it looks to me like our City Manager could not care less.

Comments are closed.