Developer plans to replace dilapidated hotel with factory-built homes

A site plan for 531 Stanford Avenue, behind Starbucks, near El Camino.

BY BRADEN CARTWRIGHT
Daily Post Staff Writer

A property owner is taking the first steps to redevelop an abandoned hotel that’s become an eyesore in Palo Alto.

The city’s Planning and Transportation Commission voted on Wednesday to recommend subdividing 531 Stanford Ave. into 20 lots, allowing for a factory-built home to go on each lot. Factory-built homes are “the wave of the future” and will be naturally affordable because they’re small, attorney Brian O’Neill said for the property owner.

The smallest lots are 18 feet wide and 50 feet long.

Commissioner Bart Hechtman said he was fascinated by the proto-type, which he hasn’t seen before.

“Intellectually, as we look for solutions to a housing crisis, I appreciate the creativity of people thinking outside the box,” he said.

The property is owned by Sophia Huang, who got in trouble with the city for renting out the Stanford Terrace Inn to foreign Stanford students.

Code Enforcement Supervisor Elisa Vargas said the converted hotel was “one of the most significant and complex code enforcement matters” that she’s encountered in her nine-year career. The city started looking into the hotel in September 2023 after firefighters responded to a medical call and noticed corroded sprinklers and broken alarms.

Fire Marshal Tamara Jasso inspected the buildings in March 2024 and found that emergency exits were blocked, ceilings were lined with plastic film, electrical wiring was corroded and a balcony was at risk of collapse.

The garage had loose paint thinner, pool chemicals, fake Christmas trees, bedding and propane tanks that could easily combust, Jasso said.

“These buildings could rapidly become fatal to occupants,” Jasso said in a statement to support demolition.

Forced to move

The city made all of the tenants move out. Most of them went to Extended Stay America in Mountain View or found somewhere closer to Stanford, Huang’s former attorney Isaac Winer said in an April 2024 interview.

Six tenants – Jun Li, Justin Jacob, Jonas Nikoloff, Ming Yang, Dongsheng Han and Dena Bahmani – sued Huang and her companies in October 2024.

Huang allegedly targeted Stanford graduate students because “they were foreigners with money and a need for housing since they were students, but completely unfamiliar with tenant laws.”

The tenants confidentially settled their lawsuit with Huang in August 2025, court records show.

Demolition ordered

The city ordered Huang to demolish the old hotel by Oct. 20, but the demolition is delayed because Huang is challenging the order with a federal lawsuit.

Huang said the city went after her because she didn’t respond to a letter about using the hotel as a city homeless shelter in June 2021.

“We believe the owners’ decision not to sell the property to the city or repurpose it in accordance with the city’s preferred high-density housing agenda provoked a campaign of retaliation,” O’Neill said in a letter in November 2025.

Unhappy either way

Residents of Palo Alto’s College Terrace neighborhood aren’t happy about the property’s dilapidated condition but don’t like the proposed development either. They sent a letter to Planning Director Jonathan Lait complaining about the factory-built homes creating fire danger and blocking daylight to their houses.

Commissioner Tom Siegel said he’s worried about the safety of young kids biking to school on Stanford Avenue.

But commissioners on Wednesday only reviewed the subdivision, not the development, and state law gives the city limited discretion to deny the project. Council will review the subdivision on Dec. 7.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.