This story first appeared in the Nov. 9 print edition of the Daily Post. We noticed that one of our competitors has re-written the story and presented it as their own work. So we’re posting the original today. Remember, if you want to read important local news stories first, pick up the Post in the mornings at 1,000 Mid-Peninsula locations.
BY BRADEN CARTWRIGHT
Daily Post Staff Writer
Legal settlements are adding up for the Palo Alto Unified School District.
The district has paid parents and former employees over $4.6 million since February to stop lawsuits, according to a review of court records and public documents.
Two more settlements are in the works. One is with former Palo Alto High School student Joshua Vasquez, who said he was bullied in 2021, and school leaders did nothing to help.
The other is with a mother who said her daughter was touched inappropriately by three boys in kindergarten at Ohlone Elementary School in February 2024. The principal and investigators allegedly downplayed the touching as a game and wouldn’t move the girl to a different class.
The district’s largest settlement was with former Fletcher Middle School teacher Peter Colombo, who sued the district after he was falsely accused of raping a student in 2002.
Colombo said former Superintendent Don Austin withheld documents showing that he worked at a different school at the time of the accusation. The board agreed to pay Colombo $3.25 million to drop his lawsuit on Feb. 10.
Austin resigned on Feb. 20. The board paid him $596,802, and both sides agreed not to sue each other.
Austin’s settlement is now the subject of a lawsuit by parents Jane Hayes Aishin and Edith Cohen, who said the board circumvented a state law that limits payouts to one year’s salary.
To get around the cap, the board paid Austin as “superintendent emeritus” through the end of the school year, in addition to a lump sum of one year’s salary.

Austin was replaced by Deputy Superintendent Trent Bahadursingh, who lasted just 22 days on the job. The board paid Bahadursingh $346,673 to resign on March 17.
The board never gave a reason for why Austin or Bahadursingh left.
The district settled a lawsuit filed by parents William Nee and Wei-Wei Lin on April 15.
Nee and Lin said they requested hundreds of documents related to special education in November 2022, but the district never released the documents in violation of the California Public Records Act.
The district agreed to pay $29,459 in attorney fees and release the documents, court records show. But Nee and Lin’s attorney David Tollner said he’s still waiting for the district to fulfill the records request.
“Nothing has come in yet. Not a single document,” Tollner said in an email on Tuesday.
The latest settlement is with special education coordinator Laurie Garcia, who said her supervisors wouldn’t reduce her workload when she was depressed.
The district paid Garcia $357,500 instead of taking the case to trial this week.
The district is in the middle of about a dozen more lawsuits, each at a different stage in the legal process.
“We’re working through all of them, but they’re really all unique,” new Superintendent Jason Glass said in an interview on Aug. 19.
Glass said he’s planning to fill an in-house general counsel position that’s been open since 2022. He said hiring an attorney can save money on contracted lawyers, who are incentivized to bill the district.
A general counsel can also make sure the district is following the law and its own policies by doing employee training, Glass said.
The next case to go to trial is from parents Todd and Kerry Feinberg, who said their son needed stitches and has a scar from cutting his face on a sharp edge of fiberglass on the playground at Ohlone. The trial is scheduled to start on March 8 and last five to seven days.

“Superintendent Emeritus” — Sounds kind of ironic. I wish I could get a deal like that. Anyway, soon the district might consider farming out its duties to an outside contractor to avoid getting sued some more. Our new trustee Linda Henigin looks like a walking, talking lawsuit target to me. She and her two allies could take a few heat-seeking missiles just for being arbitrary.
It is deeply concerning that Colombo could have—and arguably should have—been awarded $10 million or more, had the judge not made what appear to be politically motivated decisions to dismiss the majority of the claims just prior to the trial date. Given the hardship Colombo endured and the resulting turmoil within PAUSD, it is deeply troubling that Austin and his associate, Trent, were able to depart with financial payouts. Furthermore, what accountability has the individual who made the false accusations faced? It is unacceptable that she appears to have walked away from this situation without consequence.
Ridiculous. Maybe a panel of judges should select our school board and superintendent so that there’s a chance the district is lead by people who will not make decisions that lead to this.
PAUSD is gonna need to hire a full time legal team that doesn’t charge by the hour because they allegedly still have Don Austin era legal liabilities, AKA bullies, within upper management positions on the PAUSD payroll. One lawsuit in particular, Case # 26CV487750, Wei”Angie” Kung vs. PAUSD is one example of Charen Yu (PAUSD CBO) allegedly backing the bully in this case and then later even promoting him. Not helping this situation, is tone deaf like board members continuing to “thank” Charen, the person responsible for “financial stability”, who incompetently or negligently steered the district from +$100 million in reserves to a possible county takeover and $33 million deficit in just one fiscal year all while taking in a paycheck equivalent to the governor of California! This can’t be true but……. Did she allegedly go on a tour with graphs and charts telling employees what a $33 million deficit “looks like” to their potential non-employment future within the district? If true, are you freaking kidding me!? Imagine a pilot that steers you into trouble and then says “Due to my negligence, we’re having mechanical issues and will attempt an emergency landing. It will be a rough landing, so quite a few of you will not survive.” All while showing you a diagram of the damaged wing and broke landing gear and explaining how crucial they are to a safe landing. This is a worst case scenario, what happens if those employees that inevitably get “laid off” decide to start a civil class action lawsuit against Charen and PAUSD for financial incompetence? How much more money could PAUSD potentially hemorrhage? I do not know how much PAUSD paid the parcel tax “consultant”, but I’m in a giving mood, so here’s a freebie. PAUSD will not get another dime from the community until show the community ACCOUNTABILITY! #1 Except resumes or actually fire those responsible for this situation we are currently in. #2 Investigate the alleged “bullies” in upper management and fire them if evidence supports it. #3 Be fully transparent about all of it! #4 It wouldn’t hurt to finally acknowledge these mistakes and show a little remorse. Parcel tax big enough to stave off disaster will pass in March or May if all of the above are done expeditiously. You are welcome!
I almost forgot, there is one more step to absolutely guaranteeing a parcel tax passing to avert a complete financial catastrophe. But remember, no skipping steps PAUSD, accountability steps 1-4 are not negotiable. They and will still need to be done first, only then can you proceed. #5 The hiring process for Jason was an absolute blunder paying $30K to a “hiring” firm in order to trade one district’s problem for another – Don Austin. So…… in order to remedy that, he will need to show MVP type leadership and get a goodwill financial MOU deal done with both unions. I know it sounds like a Hail Mary, but I’m optimistic now that people have seen there are lots of real jobs on the line for layoffs. By Jason getting back some of the union money, perhaps the second $5000 bonus payments or getting them to furlough days would go a very long way with the community. And remember Jason, time is not on your side.