School board in transition: Shounak Dharap and Shana Segal reflect on highs and lows

Shounak Dharap and Shana Segal reflect upon their years on the Palo Alto school board.

BY BRADEN CARTWRIGHT

Daily Post Staff Writer

The Palo Alto Unified School District is saying goodbye to two board members who have had up and down tenures.

Shounak Dharap and Shana Segal, who both graduated from Gunn High School and have often voted together, had their last board meeting on Tuesday.

“These four years have brought tremendous joy, difficult decisions, and challenges, some of which have taken a personal toll,” Segal said. “Throughout, I have tried to approach this work with integrity and kindness, guided by what I believed was best for students.”

Dharap and Segal will be replaced by newcomers Linda Henigin and Avery Wang at the next meeting on Dec. 15.

Segal is just the fourth board member in the last 30 years to leave after a single term, joining Barbara Klausner in 2012, Terry Godfrey in 2018 and Jesse Ladomirak in 2024.

Tensions with Don Austin

Segal took office in December 2022 and soon ran into tension with former Superintendent Don Austin.

Austin sent Segal a series of long and angry text messages in May 2023 after her former campaign manager, Gayle McDowell, called for Austin to be fired on social media.

“You are past the point of sitting silent. Speak or you are Gayle,” Austin said in a text message.

Austin told Segal to say where she stands at the following board meeting, or he may ask her directly.

“I will have an army watching,” he wrote. 

Segal declined an interview on Austin’s text messages at the time. 

“This is a difficult situation, and I do not feel comfortable commenting about it,” she wrote in an email at the time.

Middle school math vote

Segal was on the losing side of a 3-2 vote to give students more flexibility to advance in middle school math in November 2023.

She said on Tuesday that she believes the district can support struggling students and challenge advanced students at the same time.

Segal said she’s proud of improving early literacy and opening an alternative program called Middle College High School.

Segal was board president last year, which started off with two controversial votes to eliminate Honors Biology and mandate Ethnic Studies for freshman.

Segal never missed a board or committee meeting throughout her tenure. Parents and former board members complimented her on Tuesday for always keeping students in mind and supporting employees. She is planning to return to her job as a teacher.

Dharap’s tenure

Dharap, 36, was elected to the board in 2018 as an ally to incumbent Ken Dauber. 

Dharap helped guide the district through the pandemic, when the community was divided over how quickly students should return to in-person learning.

Dauber commended Dharap on Tuesday for following public health guidelines while trying to get kids back in classrooms as soon as possible.

The Cubberley deal

Dharap sent a letter to Palo Alto City Council in March 2023 inviting offers for the district’s land at the Cubberley Community Center. The letter resulted in an agreement for the city to buy seven acres from the district for $65.5 million. Measure J, a half-cent sales tax to fund the deal, is on the verge of approval.

Dharap called out parent Edith Cohen for calling him a “token” board member in September 2023.

“The overt racism of it all is reducing my accomplishments, or my thoughts and perspectives, or my actions, down to my race — ‘I’m only on the board because I look South Asian,’” Dharap said at a board meeting.

Dharap was the subject of a failed recall last year by critics who said he weakened academic rigor and rushed approval of major, controversial changes.

“There’s a real anger toward me for being able to convince my colleagues to vote in my way,” Dharap said in an interview at the time.

Colleagues’ comments

Board members Alison Kamhi and Josh Salcman both said they’ve learned a lot from Dharap in their two years on the board.

Board member Rowena Chiu, who is set to replace Dharap as board president next year, brought up her disagreements with Segal and Dharap that started over the Ethnic Studies vote in January 2025.

After the 2025 meeting, Chiu reposted a social media post from an account, Asians Against Wokeness, that called out Executive Director of Curriculum and Instruction Danae Reynolds.

Reynolds was subject to racist comments underneath the post.

Dharap and Segal introduced a resolution at the next board meeting to re-assign Chiu from committees working directly with school employees. The resolution called for Chiu to meet with district employees, address their concerns and rebuild trust.

Salcman, Kamhi and Chiu declined to pass the resolution.

Chiu steadfast

Chiu on Tuesday invoked her past as a Harvey Weinstein rape survivor. She wrote an op-ed in the New York Times in October 2019 about Weinstein grooming her, attempting to rape her, and then pressuring her to sign a non-disclosure agreement. 

“I did not break a two-decade long silence and reclaim my agency only to sit on the dais to have my perspective diminished, minimized and suppressed,” Chiu said on Tuesday. 

Chiu said the district needs to improve its culture of bullying.

“We cannot truly champion equity and inclusion if we default to a culture of top-down compliance or discourage dissenting views,” she said.

1 Comment

  1. During his tenure on the board, Shounak Dharap consistently advanced the priorities of Michelle and Ken Dauber, including the district’s handling of the Peter Colombo matter. That situation was fundamentally mismanaged due to an apparent assumption that sustained public and professional pressure—such [Portion removed — Terms of Use violation, No. 5] his reassignment to Fletcher Middle School without adequate support—would ultimately force Mr. Colombo to step aside. Instead, this approach resulted in a $3.25 million settlement at the expense of the Palo Alto Unified School District community. For those familiar with the district’s recent history, this costly outcome remains the defining and largely unaddressed legacy of Mr. Dharap and the Daubers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.