BY BRADEN CARTWRIGHT
Daily Post Staff Writer
PG&E has stopped working on connecting a second power line to Palo Alto, according to the city manager.
The power line is supposed to protect the city from long outages like the one caused by an airplane crash in February 2010.
PG&E is cutting 15% of next year’s construction projects due to high borrowing rates following the failure of a state bill that would’ve lowered wildfire liability for utilities, City Manager Ed Shikada said in an email to council on Oct. 5, that the Post obtained via a California Public Records Act request.
The bill in question is Senate Bill 492, which Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas declined to bring to a vote on Sept. 1.
The second transmission line would connect a PG&E substation at NASA Ames in Mountain View to a Palo Alto substation at the corner of Colorado Avenue and West Bayshore Road.
The new transmission line would cost $40 to $80 million, funded by utilities throughout the state, Assistant City Manager Kiely Nose told the Utilities Advisory Commission in May 2025.
PG&E is supposed to build the line so it goes into service in 2034, Nose said.
Review will cause delay
But to meet that timeline, PG&E needs to immediately restart its environmental review, Shikada told council.
Environmental review is expected to take at least 18 months, allowing for design work in 2029.
“If no work is funded in 2027, design work is delayed further resulting in identified reliability issues without reasonable and proper mitigations,” Shikada told council.
Shikada said he’s pushing for the project to get done even sooner.
Plane crash in 2010
The city is hoping to avoid a repeat of Feb. 17, 2010, when an airplane took off and crashed into power lines in East Palo Alto.
The crash destroyed a home, and a wing hit a daycare center. The pilot and two passengers, all Tesla engineers, were killed.
The plane took out all three transmission lines that run along a single corridor from the east into Palo Alto.
Stanford Hospital, Lucile Packard Children’s Hospital and the VA Hospital were preparing to evacuate during a 12-hour outage.
PG&E happened to have a tower already built that was helicoptered in to avoid a longer citywide outage.
If the same event happened today, the outage would likely last two or three days, Senior Resources Planner Lena Perkins told the Utilities Advisory Commission in September 2024.
Close call
Palo Alto had another close call in 2021 when an airplane got entangled in two inactive wires, narrowly missing the lines that serve all of Palo Alto, Perkins said.
This kind of accident could have resulted in an outage for three to seven days, Perkins said.
The city has looked to the west to connect to a substation at the SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory on Sand Hill Road in Menlo Park, but negotiations with Stanford and the Department of Energy went on for 15 years without success.

Be the first to comment